··PolskiEnglish
Region and language

Prices include VAT of the delivery country.

CatalogueDelivery and paymentsRequest for quoteConfiguratorsArticles +48 793 996 171
Published: ·6 min read·Author:

Overcurrent protection selectivity: how to achieve and check it in a distribution board

When one circuit has a short circuit, only its breaker should trip, not the protection for the whole building. How selectivity works, where to find the data and how to check it.

Contents
Protection selectivity – moulded-case breaker, miniature circuit breakers and time-current curves

Selectivity (also called discrimination) means that in an overload or short circuit only the protective device nearest the fault operates, while the rest of the installation keeps running. At home, a lack of selectivity means the whole flat goes dark after a short in one lamp. In an office building, hospital or factory it can stop a whole floor or production line. Definitions and rules for checking circuit-breaker selectivity are in Annex A of EN 60947-2.

Total and partial selectivity

We always consider a pair of devices: the upstream device (e.g. the board's main breaker) and the downstream device (e.g. a circuit breaker).

  • Total selectivity: for any fault current up to the maximum prospective short-circuit current at the downstream device, only the downstream device operates.
  • Partial selectivity: the downstream device operates alone only up to a certain current, the selectivity limit (Is). Above it both devices may trip.

Partial selectivity is acceptable if the selectivity limit is higher than the prospective short-circuit current where the downstream device is installed. So you always need to know the short-circuit current at that point; it falls with distance from the source, which makes selectivity easier.

Overload zone and short-circuit zone

Overloads

In the overload range breakers trip with a current-dependent delay (thermal release). Selectivity is checked by comparing the time-current curves: the upstream curve must lie entirely above and to the right of the downstream curve, including tolerances. In practice this means a suitable ratio of rated currents; for modular breakers usually at least two steps of the rating series (e.g. 16 A below 32 A), although the manufacturer's curves decide.

Short circuits

At high fault currents both modular breakers trip instantaneously (magnetic release), so comparing curves is not enough. Short-circuit selectivity depends on how the devices are built: contact opening speed, current limiting by the downstream breaker, any time delay upstream. The only reliable source is therefore the manufacturer's selectivity tables, based on tests of specific device pairs.

Reading a selectivity table

Downstream devices are usually listed in rows and upstream devices in columns. Each cell gives the selectivity limit in kA or a mark for total selectivity (e.g. "T" or "total", depending on the manufacturer). Procedure:

  1. Calculate or measure the prospective short-circuit current at the downstream device.
  2. Find the pair in the table: downstream breaker (type, curve, rating) and upstream device (type, settings).
  3. Compare the selectivity limit with the short-circuit current. If it is higher, or selectivity is total, the requirement is met.
  4. The table applies to specific ranges and settings. Swapping a breaker for another model means checking again.
Note: selectivity tables cover devices from the same manufacturer or pairs it has tested. For devices from different brands, no data means short-circuit selectivity cannot be assumed.

Ways to improve selectivity

  • A moulded-case breaker (MCCB) upstream instead of a modular breaker. MCCBs such as Legrand DPX3 have adjustable releases, and electronic versions also offer a short-time delay, letting the circuit breaker clear the fault first.
  • A switch-disconnector instead of a breaker as the main device of a sub-board, where protection is provided further upstream. A switch does not trip, so it does not compete with the circuit breakers.
  • Different curves, e.g. final circuits on curve B and the group feed on curve C or D with a higher rating (always within the shock-protection requirements).
  • Fuses: for gG fuse links a rated-current ratio of at least 1.6:1 provides selectivity between links of the same type.
  • Lower short-circuit current: a longer cable to a sub-board reduces the fault current and helps selectivity, but increases voltage drop and disconnection time, so it is always a trade-off.

RCD selectivity

The same principles apply to residual current protection. With two RCDs in series, the upstream one should be selective (type S, time-delayed) and have a higher residual current, e.g. 300 mA S upstream and 30 mA on the circuits. Two ordinary 30 mA RCDs in series are not selective; either may trip. See RCD types AC, A, F and B.

Where selectivity matters most

BuildingWhy
Buildings with safety services (emergency lighting, fire pumps, smoke extraction)A trip in another circuit must not cut the supply to safety equipment
Server rooms and data centresOne faulty power supply must not shut down a whole rack or row
FactoriesDowntime is expensive; one faulty drive must not stop the whole hall
Apartment buildingsA short circuit in a flat must not cut power to the staircase

Selectivity in panel building practice

When designing a board, choose devices from one range and one manufacturer from the outset: modular breakers, MCCBs and switch-disconnectors. This gives you complete selectivity and coordination tables (including back-up protection, where a downstream device with insufficient breaking capacity is supported by the upstream one). Record in the board documentation which pairs were checked and on what data; it makes later changes easier. Breaking capacity is covered in how to choose an MCB.

Data needed to check selectivity

To assess selectivity properly, prepare the board diagram with device types and settings, the prospective short-circuit currents at successive points (main board terminals, sub-boards, the ends of long circuits) and the manufacturer's selectivity tables and time-current curves. Fault currents can be calculated from supply network data and cable lengths, or measured with a loop impedance tester in an existing installation. For adjustable breakers, record the chosen settings in the documentation; an accidental change during servicing can undo selectivity.

Selectivity is not a goal in itself: it must always go together with automatic disconnection of supply within the required time (protection against electric shock) and protection of cables against short-circuit effects. Any increase in the upstream device's delay or rating to improve selectivity must be checked against these requirements. If in doubt, the installation designer decides, not the panel builder.

Devices at automatics.pro

The catalogue includes Legrand DX3 modular breakers in MCBs, DPX3 moulded-case breakers in MCCBs and ACBs and switch-disconnectors. Plan a board with a full set of devices in the distribution board configurator.

Frequently asked questions

What is the selectivity limit?
The current up to which only the downstream device operates in a fault. Above it both devices may trip. Manufacturers give it in selectivity tables.
Are two modular breakers in series selective?
In the overload zone usually yes, if their ratings differ enough. In the short-circuit zone selectivity is usually partial, and the limit must be checked in the manufacturer's tables.
How can selectivity in a board be improved?
Most effectively with an upstream MCCB with adjustable settings and short-time delay, or a switch-disconnector instead of a breaker where protection is provided further upstream.
Are two 30 mA RCDs in series selective?
No. The upstream RCD should be selective (type S) with a higher residual current, e.g. 300 mA.

← All articles